Sign-in to Ask A Doctor - 24x7
OR
Sign in with Google
What Causes Shortness Of Breath While Standing In Water?
Question: I've had this problem for a while now, but noticed it seemed worse today. When I'm standing chest deep in water I can't breathe well. And by can't breathe well I mean like can't take a breath in AT ALL, not just trouble taking a breath. Also after a few seconds my heart was only beating once every few seconds. I'm it has something to do with the pressure to affect the lungs and heart like that, but I can't imagine what could cause me not to be able to take a breath at all. I breathe ok when I'm underwater swimming around, but the problem is standing in the water.
Brief Answer:
Likely normal phenomenon
Detailed Answer:
Thank you for asking
I read your question and i understand your concern. These breathing issues while standing in the water are normal due to buoyancy principles plus water has higher pressure than air. When it is around the chest you need more pressure than air pressure to make the lungs inflate and chest expand. This is all boyles law. Negative pressure is achieved by cest dilation and lungs inflation and water around chest is decreasing that. Thats the reason humans are meant for air and not water.
No worries. Just don't stay in water for long and swim for a while and come out. If you feel like it is more than that. There is only one way to know. Get your pulmonary functions assessed and inspiratory flow rates will tell us if there is any thing else causing it.
There is no harm in getting evaluated but i am sure it will be clear. Just rest for a while take some anxiolytics and get some labs done by visiting a doctor.
I hope it helps. Take good care of yourself and dont forget to close the discussion please.
Regards
Khan
Likely normal phenomenon
Detailed Answer:
Thank you for asking
I read your question and i understand your concern. These breathing issues while standing in the water are normal due to buoyancy principles plus water has higher pressure than air. When it is around the chest you need more pressure than air pressure to make the lungs inflate and chest expand. This is all boyles law. Negative pressure is achieved by cest dilation and lungs inflation and water around chest is decreasing that. Thats the reason humans are meant for air and not water.
No worries. Just don't stay in water for long and swim for a while and come out. If you feel like it is more than that. There is only one way to know. Get your pulmonary functions assessed and inspiratory flow rates will tell us if there is any thing else causing it.
There is no harm in getting evaluated but i am sure it will be clear. Just rest for a while take some anxiolytics and get some labs done by visiting a doctor.
I hope it helps. Take good care of yourself and dont forget to close the discussion please.
Regards
Khan
Above answer was peer-reviewed by :
Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
I know about the pressure differences, and I know sometimes other people have similar issues, but I've never heard about not being able to breathe at all and the heart rate rapidly dropping, that's just weird to me. I have a doctor appointment next week, I will mention it to her.
I do also get a little nauseous after so I don't know if that's related but would imagine it is.
I do also get a little nauseous after so I don't know if that's related but would imagine it is.
Brief Answer:
Lets wait for appointment
Detailed Answer:
Thank you for getting back
Anxiety, musculoskeletal pain which is common in swimming exercises, and acid reflux problems too can cause breathing difficulties. Lets wait for the appointment. Try anxiolytics and see if it relieves this dyspnea and may cause psychological dyspnea.
I hope it helps.
Regards
Khan
Lets wait for appointment
Detailed Answer:
Thank you for getting back
Anxiety, musculoskeletal pain which is common in swimming exercises, and acid reflux problems too can cause breathing difficulties. Lets wait for the appointment. Try anxiolytics and see if it relieves this dyspnea and may cause psychological dyspnea.
I hope it helps.
Regards
Khan
Above answer was peer-reviewed by :
Dr. Chakravarthy Mazumdar
Answered by
Get personalised answers from verified doctor in minutes across 80+ specialties
