Can Asthma And COPD Be Diagnosed With Minimal Medical Tests?
My sister has had severe cough, shortness of breath for three months which has not responded to three different antibiotics. She has also been on several rounds of prednisone and been using Symbicort daily per MD orders. Nothing has given her any relief. She had a bronchoscopy performed yesterday which noted inflammation. They took samples & she will get results in about 5 days. It was implied that it was asthma though she has not had a complete set of PFTs nor a methacholine test. This is a very conscientious adult who has eaten correctly, walked 4-6 miles daily, serious tennis player who never gets sick and yet has this recurring problem since the first of this year. She is a breast cancer survivor of 10+ yrs. We are both frustrated by the swift diagnosis of first COPD & now asthma with minimal testing by two different doctors. Her PCP is also not satisfied. Can asthma really been this persistent coming out of the blue?
Hello and Welcome to ‘Ask A Doctor’ service. I have reviewed your query and here is my advice.
Yes, asthma can be seen in adult life. It is known as adult onset asthma. It behaves similarly to COPD. And your are right, diagnosis of asthma or COPD should only be based on PFT (Pulmonary Function Test). So in my opinion, you should insist for PFT. If PFT is showing obstructive defect with bronchodilator reversibility then it is asthma. But if PFT is showing obstructive defect without reversibility then it is COPD.
Hope I have solved your query. I will be happy to help you further. Wishing good health to your sister. Thanks.
I find this answer helpful
1 Doctor agrees with this answer
You found this answer helpful
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer.
For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service
[Sample answer]
We use cookies in order to offer you most relevant experience and using this website you acknowledge that you have already read and understood our
Privacy Policy
Can Asthma And COPD Be Diagnosed With Minimal Medical Tests?
Hello and Welcome to ‘Ask A Doctor’ service. I have reviewed your query and here is my advice. Yes, asthma can be seen in adult life. It is known as adult onset asthma. It behaves similarly to COPD. And your are right, diagnosis of asthma or COPD should only be based on PFT (Pulmonary Function Test). So in my opinion, you should insist for PFT. If PFT is showing obstructive defect with bronchodilator reversibility then it is asthma. But if PFT is showing obstructive defect without reversibility then it is COPD. Hope I have solved your query. I will be happy to help you further. Wishing good health to your sister. Thanks.