I am a nurse. Twelve weeks ago, I was moving a 485 pound woman and after the episode I felt like my shoulder had separated. I had to strap the arm to my body with a belt because it felt so unstable. By the second day I could not lift it. Any subtle movement, I would feel it. MRI showed fluid in the capsule, no tear. MRI arthrogram didn t show a slap tear, although every time my ortho guy does the tests in his office, they come up positive. This is workers comp case, so they can t do surgery unless definitive objective evidence. Physical therapy has made things worse. I have not gotten any better. Today I am back to strapping my arm down because I am sick of the feeling of looseness . I m seeing the top shoulder guy in the area. Got any ideas? Is it still a slap tear just not showing up?