HealthCareMagic is now Ask A Doctor - 24x7 | https://www.askadoctor24x7.com

Get your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties
159 Doctors Online

By proceeding, I accept the Terms and Conditions

Dr. Andrew Rynne
MD
Dr. Andrew Rynne

Family Physician

Exp 50 years

HCM Blog Instant Access to Doctors
HCM BlogQuestions Answered
HCM Blog Satisfaction

What Causes Confabulation And Delusional Denial?

Hello, my name is Bryan Oftedahl. I’ve recently been reading up on the intriguing dysfunction of Hemispatial Neglect. I’m not so curious about the dysfunction itself, more the patient’s reactions to anybody pointing it out to them, their denial of the Neglect and the confabulations they come up with. When a victim of hemispatial neglect is asked to clap they raise the hand of their unaffected side and swing it back and forth in front of them in a kind of half clap while the hand of their affected side remains paralyzed and motionless. When asked if they’re clapping the patient claims that they are. When prodded about the certainty of their clapping the patient insists that they are. When it is pointed out that their clapping makes no sound the patient shrugs the point off, claiming that they never make noise when they do something. Instead of admit the obvious truth they choose to confabulate. I quote a bit from a Blakeslee book, The Body Has a Mind of Its Own:      If prodded for hours, patients make up stories to explain their lack of action. One woman said her arm ‘went for a walk’. A man claimed that his motionless arm did not belong to him. When it was placed in his right visual field, he insisted it was not his.      “Whose arm is it?” Dr. Berti asked.      “Yours.”      “Are you sure? Look here, I only have two hands.”      The patient replied, “What can I say? You have three wrists. You should have three hands.”      This denial and these rather absurd confabulations remind me very much of Leon Festinger’s book When Prophecy Fails. The group they were investigating - UFO occultists - were constantly making prophecies about when the UFO’s would arrive and whisk them off to safety along with prophecies concerning an apocalyptic flooding of the lands. Whenever the prophecies failed, instead of admitting the obvious truth, they came up with all sorts of often absurd confabulations and denials not unlike the patients with hemispatial neglect. I understand cognitive dissonance and that denial and even confabulation are a common reaction to it. I understand these people aren’t being liars or idiots, they genuinely believe these claims.      I guess my question is multifaceted: •     Is there anyway that this form of denial/confabulation taking place with the hemispatial neglect patients and UFO occultists is the same kind of denial and can it be the same kind of denial/confabulation used by Creationists in their denial and attempts to debunk Evolution? •     Is there a neurological basis for this denial/confabulation - i.e. is neurology aware of a general region within the brain, or network of systems, that is a likely culprit? •     Do you have any recommendations as far as literature concerning these issues?
Fri, 11 Dec 2020
Report Abuse
General & Family Physician 's  Response
Hi,

Human brain is a fascinating organ, your observation are very admirable but such disassociation and confabulation helps person to be in control. The ultimate reality is that you and I also confabulate every time we describe the past experience. The information as it comes only stays abut 15 seconds or less in it full extent or original form since its a huge chunk of data to put an entire event into a film without missing any thing. How many time you see same movie and still find the new stuff?

The process of selective record keeping what a brain needs for recreation /recall of past event is done in each case (something like zip files on computer / compressing a file to save data space). For people with hemineglect syndrome is more enhanced that we can see it because we are observer. There is as show called "BRAIN GAMES" on national geography channel SEASON - 4 Episode 6 (memory) which will explain you in much more details about what I am sharing you. For literature I can only suggest neurology and psychology (medical books)

Take care. Hope I have answered your question. Let me know if I can assist you further.

Regards,
Dr. Jay Patel, General & Family Physician
I find this answer helpful

Note: For further follow up on related General & Family Physician Click here.
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer. For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service [Sample answer]
Share on
 

Related questions you may be interested in


Loading Online Doctors....
What Causes Confabulation And Delusional Denial?

Hi, Human brain is a fascinating organ, your observation are very admirable but such disassociation and confabulation helps person to be in control. The ultimate reality is that you and I also confabulate every time we describe the past experience. The information as it comes only stays abut 15 seconds or less in it full extent or original form since its a huge chunk of data to put an entire event into a film without missing any thing. How many time you see same movie and still find the new stuff? The process of selective record keeping what a brain needs for recreation /recall of past event is done in each case (something like zip files on computer / compressing a file to save data space). For people with hemineglect syndrome is more enhanced that we can see it because we are observer. There is as show called BRAIN GAMES on national geography channel SEASON - 4 Episode 6 (memory) which will explain you in much more details about what I am sharing you. For literature I can only suggest neurology and psychology (medical books) Take care. Hope I have answered your question. Let me know if I can assist you further. Regards, Dr. Jay Patel, General & Family Physician