Sign-in to Ask A Doctor - 24x7
OR
Sign in with Google
Suggest Treatment For Complicated Childhood Psychological Trauma
Question: Hello. I am trying to process my childhood trauma related to some physical, and a lot of emaotional child abuse. I'm seeing a psychologist since the past 6 months, but she claims that she doesn't make diagnosises on anyone. I'm a bit confused, because I feel like putting a label on the after effects of what I'm feeling will help me more actively become involved in healing it, but I'm not sure if this is just a misperception, like, if seeing the psychologist without a diagnosis should be enough. I don't particularly like the idea of drugs or medications, but I would be open to seeing a psychiatrist if he would be able to give me a more active treatment plan etc. COuld i please have your professional opinion on how to proceed properly?
Brief Answer:
Seeing a psychiatrist would benefit
Detailed Answer:
Hi, thanks for writing through HCM.
I have read your query and understood your concerns.
Detailed history and interview are required for making psychiatric diagnosis. It may take 2 to 3 consultation to make a diagnosis even for a psychiatrist for a complicated childhood psychological trauma.
Psychologist does not have knowledge of how to proceed for a diagnosis. Their basic training is to talk and apply psychological tests like rorschach, TAT and so may others. They do not have knowledge of drugs and they can not prescribe it.
I feel that you should visit a psychiatrist and tell about your current symptoms and emotional issues. He will find a trail which will take him to your childhood issues and then he will ask more details to make a diagnosis. After making the diagnosis, he can tell you about the possible treatment options.
If there will be a diagnostic confusion then he may refer you to a psychologist for evaluation and testing like rorschach or thematic apperception test etc.
In my opinion, for a psychiatric illness based on psychological issues of childhood, drugs won't help. It may be possible that you can have benefit from psychoanalysis sessions instead of seeing a psychologist. Psychoanalyst is professionally trained psychiatrist in finding the childhood psychological issues and making them correct.
You can also ask the same psychiatrist that psychoanalysis would help or not.
Hope I have answered your query. If you have further query then I shall be happy to help.
Wish you good health.
Seeing a psychiatrist would benefit
Detailed Answer:
Hi, thanks for writing through HCM.
I have read your query and understood your concerns.
Detailed history and interview are required for making psychiatric diagnosis. It may take 2 to 3 consultation to make a diagnosis even for a psychiatrist for a complicated childhood psychological trauma.
Psychologist does not have knowledge of how to proceed for a diagnosis. Their basic training is to talk and apply psychological tests like rorschach, TAT and so may others. They do not have knowledge of drugs and they can not prescribe it.
I feel that you should visit a psychiatrist and tell about your current symptoms and emotional issues. He will find a trail which will take him to your childhood issues and then he will ask more details to make a diagnosis. After making the diagnosis, he can tell you about the possible treatment options.
If there will be a diagnostic confusion then he may refer you to a psychologist for evaluation and testing like rorschach or thematic apperception test etc.
In my opinion, for a psychiatric illness based on psychological issues of childhood, drugs won't help. It may be possible that you can have benefit from psychoanalysis sessions instead of seeing a psychologist. Psychoanalyst is professionally trained psychiatrist in finding the childhood psychological issues and making them correct.
You can also ask the same psychiatrist that psychoanalysis would help or not.
Hope I have answered your query. If you have further query then I shall be happy to help.
Wish you good health.
Note: For further guidance on mental health, Click here.
Above answer was peer-reviewed by :
Dr. Prasad
Answered by
Get personalised answers from verified doctor in minutes across 80+ specialties
