Sign-in to Ask A Doctor - 24x7
OR
Sign in with GoogleGet your health question answered instantly from our pool of 18000+ doctors from over 80 specialties
Are There Any Definitive Tests That Could Detect Malignancy Which Don T Include Biopsies, CAT Scans, Or Any Other Invasive Tests?
Dear Doctor:
Are there any definitive tests that could detect malignancy which don't include biopsies, PET scans, CAT scans, or any other invasive tests? Do you know of a Dr. Tucker who invented a Hemotoxilin(sp?) test?
Many thanks for your insight in this matter. The information is for someone I love very much.
Carol
Are there any definitive tests that could detect malignancy which don't include biopsies, PET scans, CAT scans, or any other invasive tests? Do you know of a Dr. Tucker who invented a Hemotoxilin(sp?) test?
Many thanks for your insight in this matter. The information is for someone I love very much.
Carol
Thu, 18 Apr 2013
Hi carol
The diagnosis of a malignancy involves the following process
1. High clinical suspicion / Clinical probability ( based on the history of specific complaints/Age & Sex of the person/ethnicity/family history/life style related factors of the person etc)
2. screening tests ( usually simple, cost effective & non invasive tests )
3. Confirmatory tests (usually an invasive test like Biopsy)
is there a definitive test to detect malignancy, which are non invasive..i must say no. Since all theses non invasive tests are not very sensitive ( Ability to detect a particular disease in question) or specific ( ability to rule out particular disease in question). That means some uncertainty will be there what ever may be the result of a screening test.
But if you can mention the specific malignancy about which you are concerned, we can answer you better
take care
The diagnosis of a malignancy involves the following process
1. High clinical suspicion / Clinical probability ( based on the history of specific complaints/Age & Sex of the person/ethnicity/family history/life style related factors of the person etc)
2. screening tests ( usually simple, cost effective & non invasive tests )
3. Confirmatory tests (usually an invasive test like Biopsy)
is there a definitive test to detect malignancy, which are non invasive..i must say no. Since all theses non invasive tests are not very sensitive ( Ability to detect a particular disease in question) or specific ( ability to rule out particular disease in question). That means some uncertainty will be there what ever may be the result of a screening test.
But if you can mention the specific malignancy about which you are concerned, we can answer you better
take care
I find this answer helpful
3 Doctors agree with this answer
Disclaimer: These answers are for your information only and not intended to replace your relationship with your treating physician.
This is a short, free answer.
For a more detailed, immediate answer, try our premium service
[Sample answer]
Related questions you may be interested in
Recent questions on Biopsy
Loading Online Doctors....